I stumbled across this today- Paranominal is a clearing-house website for weird stuff stories of many different kinds- UFOs, Ghosts, Cryptozoology, you know the drill. Seems like a fun place to spend a lonely fall evening creeping yourself out.
Although, if you really want to creep yourself out, check out paranormal.about.com’s True Stories sent in by readers. They post a collection of them each month, and they range from touching, to creepy, to outright weird. Lots of stuff here on Black-Eyed Kids, Living Shadows, and other phenomena that you don’t see mentioned much.
I would also be remiss not to mention a friend’s new podcast about weird things from Nova Scotia- North of Reality. The show is just getting started, but looks like it will be a lot of fun, since the hosts Jack and Antonia are both really into weird phenomena.